Since the Stonewall Riots, we have made significant progress in developing a form of Gay Pride around many issues, legally and pubically. Despite these gains, the main focus of Gay Pride continues to be on sex, Hollywood celebrities, drag, and body image. It is time for a new revolution, a new self-image, a new focus away from the ol’ way of being to a newer one that goes deeper to the heart of who we are. We need a new way of talking about “our Pride” in being who we are as gay men and as men.
While recognizing our contributions to both art, science, politics, metaphysics, and embracing our fetishes, and publically celebrating our kink, and in many ways being pioneers on most of those fronts, the focus remains centered on who we have sex with and viewing ourselves almost totally through the lens of our bodies or through the lens of what prestige we hold in the hetero world of career and profession. In our 20s and 30s our homones are raging and spewing forth, egos developing, boundaries challenged and probed, social skills tested, sex and sexual positions explored, and flirtateousness enjoyed. Posing and posturing in bars, on street corners, in cafes, bathhouses, gyms, online and anywhere else we can get recognition is much of the past time and prideful enjoyment of having “come out” of that closet of solitude and isolation into the light of day, and hopefully, the embrace of another man or other men. All of the above activity is important and necessary for our own individual development as men. Yet, isn’t it time to move on from measuring the worth of one another and ourselves by our physique?
I sense, perhaps as a byproduct of my own aging process, that there must be something more grounded and just as enjoyable than simply and only being seen as sexually desirable. What the Rainbow Flag has most represented is sexual freedom and the freedom to be recognized as ‘equals’ among men. The Rainbow Flag can symbolize more. I think we need a new paradigm to live out and be proud of besides sexual freedom.
What would a new paradigm look like, feel like, focus upon? Some of the elements of the new paradigm, for me, are vulnerability versus intransigence, safety versus controlling, responsibility versus manipulation, authenticity versus wearing masks, courage versus shame. As gay men we have something profound to offer to the heterosexual world, especially to the world of other men. It’s time we explored, clarified, defined, and “shouted out” what that is or may be for us.
In the developmental stage of boys it’s imperative that the boy separate from his mother. Many a boy goes at great length to declare his independence from his mother by becoming hyper-masculine, rejecting all that smacks of femininity. If he brings this endeavor into adulthood, he demonstrates an aloofness, a disconnect, from all that is stereotypically feminine, such as expressing vulnerability, feelings of tenderness and compassion, any leanings toward whatever may be interpreted by other men (or women) as feminine characteristics or values. He may even set the feminine as something to be honored and cherished, but not imitated.
This separation from “mother” and the feminine is also entered into by gay boys to create their own identity and form of masculinity. The drive to reject or stand in opposition to anything feminine, but not always, is also on the agenda of most gay boys. There are effeminate men, who are heterosexual, but the stereotypical description of gay men is that that we are all effeminate. Though this stereotype is gradually breaking down, there are many gay men who go out of their way to state they are “straight-acting”, enjoy sports, are into muscles, control, Domination, etc. They seem to go out of their way to declare that they indeed are masculine and protest loudly if they are ‘accused’ of being swishy or sissy or anything that would indicate any femininity within them. There are other gay men who delight in being overly feminine in appearance as well as behavior and in their use of language. They may seem “in your face” about being ‘different’ and want everyone to know it.
It is, in my view, the gay man who embodies with pride his feminine and masculine qualities that speaks loudly to both extremes of gay men as well as of straight men. Perhaps the best ‘label’ that speaks to those of us who are gay is “two spirited”, embodying the best of both genders, though this label has it’s own drawbacks as well. “Two-spirited” in Native American traditions speaks of a man who dresses as a woman (e.g. “berdache”) and, therefore, does not include all of us gay men. Perhaps focusing on the harmonious and integrated relationship between the two extremes of masculinity and femininity doesn’t have a name/label yet. I don’t see us as a third gender, but a synthesis of the two genders as men. Unpacking this disarray of possibilities isn’t going to be easy. Yet, we must move forward in defining who we are with clarity and courage. Who are we as men?
The Old Paradigm
In the old paradim the emphasis has been placed upon “coming out” and standing tall, speaking our truth about our sexual orientation, sometimes discreetly, sometimes boldly. Likewise, the emphasis has been on our physicality, what is physically attractive about another man. So, we have formed various subgroupings within the so-called ‘gay community’: bears, twinks, jocks, gym rats, leathermen with added emphasis on penis size, balls, bubble butt, pecs, biceps. Another obvious focus has been on having as much sex as you desire. The final focus has been on finding a life-long partner as if this is the goal of ‘every gay man’.
A New Paradigm
If we were to follow a new paradigm, what would it contain? What would it speak to about who we are?
Vulnerability versus Intransigence
Vulneraility has typically been ascribed to females. Vulnerability is seen as a weakness to be avoided at all cost by many, if not most, men. Gay men have too often been hypersensitive to being found ‘vulnerable’, like most men. We become hypercritical when any form of ‘criticism’ comes our way, whether it is deserving or not. We seem to be wired to ‘jump’ and defend ourselves in ways that straight men don’t have to bare. This is understandable! In many circles if we are ‘found out’, we will be ridiculed, bullied, lose our jobs and housing, and hospitalized or murdered. So, it makes perfect sense that we would be hypersensitive to our surroundings, ever on the watch for harm coming our way, even from other gay men.
Emotionally too many of us have tended to be rigid, intransigent, and fear-based. A new paradigm calls us out of that stance, that posture of fear and shame, into one of self-awareness, and being able to be vulnerable in the expression of our feelings, our fears, our hopes, our desires with one another at least.
Safety versus Controlling
“Curiosity comes out of a sense of safety, regidity out of being vigilant to threats.” (Hold Me Tight by Sue Johnson) It’s paramount that we find ways to create safety for each other with each other. Instead of controlling, hiding or fleeing from our feelings and those of others, we simply express them with sensitivity and respect. Why is it that it seems so many gay men fear intimacy? Because we don’t know how to create emotional safety for ourselves and with others. Rather than fear rejection, abandonment, ridicule from other gay men, we may come to realize that discovering what another man is like is creating safety for each other.
Responsibility versus Manipulation
How many times have you read an online profile, seen an online photo, of someone and then discover the profile doesn’t speak to who they are, and the photo was of many years earlier? How many times have you been ‘stood up’ by a guy who ‘no showed’, or keeps chatting, chatting, chatting and never makes a commitment to meet in person? How many times have you made commitments and the other man never follows through on what he has promised? Is this simply fear and shame, or something else? It speaks volumes about taking out ability to take responsibility for one’s self.
Authenticity versus Wearing Masks
If I am going to be authentic, it will demand courage as well as self-awareness. Courage to simply be myself, warts and all, and make a commitment for change where change is needed and wanted. We all wear masks in our lives, testing out the turf, testing out whether or not revealing who we are to another is safe, finding out if the other person can be trusted with seeing who I am. It seems that too often when we drop our masks and let another man into our private space, it is not safe. Gossip too often rules the way we treat each other! One-upsmanship, ‘get him before he gets me’, that macho competitiveness that rules the heterosexual male world continues to reign in our own gay male world.
Courage versus Shame
Shame is feeling exposed, found out, discovered as unacceptable. Courage is facing our fears and addressing them. Why live in shame, and perhaps not even being aware of the fact that it is shame ruling our lives? Building up each other’s self-esteem, challenging and affirming what is our best rather than what is our weakness may be a very new way of relating to one another if we see each other as human and not simply as a possible sex object, play partner.
Emotional Closeness
Many of us have close friends who we can rely upon, who we trust, who are safe for us to be around. Many of us have men in our lives who look at us as more than simply “gay”, but as men who deserve to love and be loved. It takes a definite level of trust to get emotionally close to another person, to another man. It takes honesty, loyalty, self-awareness, and the courage to live from our core and authentically. Perhaps we don’t know how “to do it”, how to build up safe bonds of trust with another, so we take the easier, most often treaded road of sex with “NSA” than to do the hard work of self-discovery with another!
Whether we are bottoms, tops, versatile when it comes to sex, and sex is indeed extremely important, isn’t it far greater to be with a man/men who is emotionally available and is capable of love and authenticity.
I am very interested in hearing what you have to say about what elements you believe would form the foundation of a new paradigm to follow proudly as “gay” MEN.